At the Movies: Podcast Transcripts
Sense and Sensibility & A Talent For Murder
Tuesday, November 10, 2026Intro
[upbeat music plays]
MARIE WESTHAVER:
Hello, and welcome to At The Movies with Mike and Marie, a show where two film professors talk about movies. I'm Marie Westhaver.
MIKE GIULIANO:
And I'm Mike Giuliano.
MARIE WESTHAVER:
And today we're going to talk about the new version of Sense and Sensibility and the Helen Mirren film, A Talent for Murder. Starting with Sense and Sensibility-- I don't know how big of a fan of Austen you are, but this movie has been made-- the Jane Austen movies have been made and remade. So let's start off with, why a new one? So set us up for the new Sense and Sensibility.
[Sense and Sensibility]
MIKE GIULIANO:
That really is a great opening question. Filmmakers, as you say, keep returning to Jane Austen, and with good reason. You have really good literary sourcing there.
In this particular case, with Sense and Sensibility, I would point out that there is a 1995 version of this Austen novel, which is a really good film, and it's got a lot of top-notch A-list talent attached to it. The director's Ang Lee-- no slouch in the director's chair. The screenplay is by its star, Emma Thompson, and indeed, she won the Academy Award for Best Adapted Screenplay. And then it's such a starry cast in this, certainly in the years they've had since then as well-- Kate Winslet, Hugh Grant, Alan Rickman.
So part of me thinks, well, it's a really good version of it. Do we need another one? On the other side of that question, and the other answer is, well, it's been what, 31 years? I mean, it's been a while. Yeah, it's kind of daunting to realize how long it's been since that one came out. So why not?
So in any event, invariably, people will end up saying which version. The fans of Jane Austen are really diligent in not only reading the books, but judging all the film versions and so on. And so it's kind of a side profession for them almost to do that. And so in any event, people will hold up this new version against that 1995 version.
What I'll point out, just at simply the level of distinction, what makes this one different is that the new version is earthier and darker. I mean, literally darker in terms of cinematography and just the ambience, that way. And it's a beautifully shot film. And in that respect, you do get the parlor scenes you expect in a Jane Austen adaptation.
But you know what? A lot of our time here is actually spent outdoors with considerable hand-held camera work in the natural world. It never quite becomes a Terrence Malick film in terms of people spinning in the fields, but it has that quality to it. People like communing with nature and with each other, and that gives it a different quality. Now, again, it's very subjective as to which version you prefer, but this one does set itself apart that way.
Also, setting it apart somewhat is that there's a strong female cast not only in front of the camera, but behind it here. And not that the other version was totally lacking in that-- after all, Emma Thompson with the screenplay. But here the director of the film is a woman, Georgia Oakley, and the screenwriter, Diana Reid, is also a woman. And when I was hosting a screening of this for a public event, during the Q&A, somebody pointed out that Jane Austen also was a woman, which I think I was aware of already. [LAUGHS] So there's a lot of female talent attached to this.
Now, as we get into the particulars of casting here and storyline and so on, let me turn it back over to my co-host.
MARIE WESTHAVER:
Well, I will say I do love Jane Austen. Sense and Sensibility is my favorite of her books, and I absolutely loved the Ang Lee version because, like you said, Ang Lee is a master of what he does. Emma Thompson did a great job with the screenplay and infused it with a lot of wit that I think the book also has. Also, there's a famous story about how she had it saved on a flash drive, and then she couldn't retrieve it, so she had to call some friends. So it was Emma Thompson, and Stephen Fry, and Hugh Laurie all hunkered down over this flash drive trying to resuscitate it, get it to come back from the dead.
I like telling my students that story because, hasn't that happened to all of us where you have some really important document you absolutely cannot afford to lose. And then there's a moment where you think you might have lost it. So I like the story behind it. I love all the people that you mentioned that are in the Ang Lee version. That version also does the details of the era absolutely perfectly.
But I will say, the new version, even though it doesn't have any of those things I just mentioned, I absolutely loved it. I loved the feel of it. For example, in the Ang Lee version, everybody's got that distinctive-- the costumes, and the curled hair, and everything. And in this one, everybody's hair is just flowing. No one ever, at any time, picks up a hairbrush and tries to brush their hair. Everybody looks extremely unkempt. And you're right. They're outside a lot. So the flowing hair kind of works with the wildness of the outdoors.
I kept thinking, this actually looks like the Bronte sisters rather than the characters from Sense and Sensibility. But I thought it was good for the movie that the actors are kind of semi-unknown, because I hadn't realized how much I liked the Ang Lee version simply because I liked the people playing the characters, and I thought the acting was very believable. I thought the chemistry between the characters was very believable and much more intense, in a way, emotionally. I thought all that really worked.
MIKE GIULIANO:
You make a really interesting observation that the tenor, the tone of this new version actually hearkens to the subsequent romantic literature, more from the Brontes, if you will. It's as if somehow the Brontes had rewritten Jane Austen or something. It's not quite as quote, unquote "genteel." The gentility very much factors into the storyline here as well.
And it's funny also, when you mention the unkempt hair, nobody using a hairbrush, when I was leading that audience Q&A, people were making an observation like, didn't they have enough of a budget for a hairbrush? We were talking about that. And I thought, well, they're outdoors, and the wind is blowing, and it's blowing around them. And without having to be heavy-handed with the dialogue, you can talk about lives themselves that are somewhat unkempt.
And this is where the new version does set up a very effective contrast between what I'll call country manners and city manners. In any version of it, that's going to factor in. But here you do have those parlor or drawing room scenes that I alluded to before, where people are at least relatively well put-together in terms of costuming, and hair, and so on. But then outside, well, nature takes its course, and human nature will take its course as well.
And then without getting into the particulars of the storyline in terms of various marital matchups or potential match ups, the relative honesty and integrity of the country folk, as opposed to, yes, the highbrow, sophisticated gentility of London life, but also the hypocrisy, and the social climbing, and the insincerity, and all of that. And this film actually does a really good job of that juxtaposition of country ways and city ways.
And so, again, even though, push come to shove, I prefer the Ang Lee version-- and people put me on the spot, which is better? Which do you like more? OK, ready answer. Ang Lee, I'll stick with that. But that's not to slight this new version. It has its own identity.
MARIE WESTHAVER:
And I think it's exceptionally well cast. I mean, Elinor, obviously, has to carry the movie. But there's so many other side stories. And the Marianne-Colonel Brandon story is wonderful. I love the intensity they give to Marianne. She feels very much like an impulsive person who's got romantic ideas in her head. She plays that to the hilt. Colonel Brandon seems to have so much more inner world than Alan Rickman in the Ang Lee version. But I didn't notice it when I was watching Alan Rickman because he was Alan Rickman. I love him in almost everything he does.
MIKE GIULIANO:
Marie, what's a really interesting observation you just made is that a great measure of the success of the Ang Lee version is-- you're absolutely right-- actors we want to watch. And so as you're watching them, they do play the characters extremely well. But you're also thinking, star performances or good-looking actor performances, that kind of thing. And in this version, the cast, for the most part, all seem to have hyphenated names. So it takes a while to get used to the length of the name.
But beyond that, I mean, Daisy Edgar-Jones plays Elinor, and a few other actors you may recognize, but it's not like an instantly recognizable star cast. And that, as you say very smartly there, that may play to the advantage here of the fact that you really focus on these people as characters, and in terms of the siblings, the sisterly bonds, we've been talking about Elinor. She's the one who would have sense, if you will, and Marianne, the one with sensibility. It's put that way.
But I think this version then really does throw you into the dynamics of that kind of sister to sister or within a family relationships in a way where you're not thinking so much about the actor, you're just thinking about the character. And I think you're right. I think that plays to advantage here.
MARIE WESTHAVER:
You also get a sense of how powerless the women are because the men inherit the property. And they also give you some wonderful minor characters. The person playing Miss Lucy Steele is just wonderfully awful, and the sister-in-law, Fanny, is also wonderfully evil. So I just found so much to enjoy about it.
I will say, the one thing that I thought was a real clunker was, a duel? Really?
MIKE GIULIANO:
Thank you for saying that because during our audience discussion I've been referring to, that point came up. And somebody who knew the etiquette of dueling better than I did questioned that, too. Without spoiling the particulars in the storyline there'll be a duel near the end, but as to whether there would be one, and then how it's conducted, there were some-- not quite red flags, but just sort of like question marks on it that way.
To me, that seemed, I'm tempted to say, unnecessary or at least distracting. It seemed to stand out, really, from the tenor or mood of most of it, and it seemed like a more conventional bit of movie-making melodrama. Let's have a duel at this point. It just stood out in a pejorative way. And so, yes, given my druthers, I would shoot the scene-- or I would not shoot the scene. They won't have to worry about shooting each other. I would not shoot the scene. I would have left that out.
The other really good point you just made had to do with one of the challenges with a novelist like Jane Austen is you have three or four principal players. You have your main protagonists or antagonists, but then you have those huge supporting casts. I mean, in lengthy novels, you're going to have-- and so much of it is, I call it, quasi-incestuous family relations. Like, who's related to whom, who might marry a cousin, all that sort of stuff. In a novel, you can spend a few hundred pages sorting all that out.
In a film, it's a real challenge to establish those secondary characters. And watching any version of Jane Austen, unless you've read the book recently, it can take a little while sometimes watching it to make some of those connections. Well, wait a minute, which one is she engaged to? What are the connections here? And no, it doesn't hurt the film. It's just you're being alert to make those connections.
Among the supporting players-- you mentioned a few of the good ones, but my favorite one actually was an actress whose name may be familiar, Fiona Shaw, who plays a distant relative, Mrs. Jennings. And it's comic relief, basically. But what I loved about that character and about the performance is she is both annoying and endearing. She's like that elderly houseguest who comes in and who just is a motormouth, and she freely comments on everything, and she can be really irritating that way. So you find yourself thinking, gee, when is she going to leave?
But then also, well, she's really kind of amusing, and she is well-intentioned, and she really brings life to the parlor, if you will. And it's really a great compliment to the actor here that she's able to simultaneously convey that sense of someone who's both endearing and annoying, and within the same sentence, even. It's like you want to say, well, shut up already, but then you're laughing at whatever she just said, so you're enjoying it.
MARIE WESTHAVER:
The character-- I remember in the book-- is very annoying. It's one of those strains in social life where you have to treat people, especially people who have money and power, everybody needs to be treated with respect. And she's such a buffoon. And yet this performance, there's an underlying kindness. You're not just forgiving her gaucheness. You genuinely like her.
MIKE GIULIANO:
Well, she's gauche. You're right. But the fundamental thing is that she's sincere. She's honest. She voices her opinion, however fatuous it might seem sometimes, but sometimes insightful, whatever. She doesn't have some of the social veneer that the London types have, right, where, yes, on the surface, they know how to drink their tea and say nice things to you. But what are they thinking? What are they scheming at? Whatever's going through her mind comes out of her mouth.
[laughter]
And it's there. And it's there, and you deal with it. She would never stab you in the back, much less challenge you to a duel or something. She's really fundamentally a good person. I'm not sure I'd want to have her living in my household or be a guest all that often.
[laughter]
But I have to acknowledge that.
MARIE WESTHAVER:
Yeah, well, so many great characters. And honestly, I think a very good remake of a very famous story. But let's move on to A Talent for Murder, which is based on a real-life person, Patricia Highsmith. But the storyline goes hither and yon, with Helen Mirren playing the irascible and hard to wrap your head around character of Patricia Highsmith.
[A Talent For Murder]
MIKE GIULIANO:
Yeah. So years ago, I met Helen Mirren at the Telluride Film Festival. And I've always absolutely adored her as an actor and also as a person. And what's great is, as you and I speak today, she's 81. She's still with us. She's had a very long film career. Without going through the filmography, just in terms of how good she can be as an actor, I always think about and marvel at her title performance in The Queen in 2006. She won the Academy Award for Best Actress. She is Queen Elizabeth II. It's just such a carefully calibrated performance. I mean, I'm actually visualizing scenes from it as I'm describing that. That's how much I loved it.
And so for me, I want to see her with whatever she does. And admittedly, because she became a well-known actor, she's done some quote, unquote "art house"-type films. She's also done more commercial stuff, and I realize that. But she's the kind of actor-- you know what she reminds me of, in a way, one of her compatriots?
I think of a Judi Dench type, where sometimes they get hired to be in big budget, adventure movies or whatever, and they may only pop up for two or three scenes, and they always have a commanding presence. I think, well, whatever I thought of the rest of the film, hey, that was Helen Mirren. Hey, that was Judi Dench or something.
And let them enjoy the paychecks they finally get. Because they all had strong stage credits early in their careers. They toured the provinces, they did the stage circuits and all. Now that they've had movie success, not only they make big budget movies, but let them enjoy that.
So this is a case where it's kind of ironic that I love watching her in A Talent for Murder. I wish she were in it a bit more often. In terms of Patricia Highsmith, this is no secret that she was a very disagreeable person, and in the film she has some scathing comments. You name the ethnic group, or race, or whatever, and she'll have something nasty to say. And not that I'm going to defend her on this point, but I would call her an equal opportunity bigot. So if you feel somehow your identity's been insulted, hey, you're in good company. She hates most of humanity.
And so the gist of the storyline here is that she's written five of the Tom Ripley novels. And of course, we're talking about her now because when you think about the various screen versions, most famously of Matt Dillon, we know even if people haven't read Patricia Highsmith, they've seen various versions of this on screen. So she's familiar in that way.
So anyway, the gist of this. Alden Ehrenreich plays a totally made-up fictitious character named Edward Ridgeway, who this character works for her New York publisher. And the publisher, understandably or avariciously, wants her to write a sixth Ripley novel. She is living in near seclusion in Switzerland. Her neighbors even barely know her. Most of her time is spent smoking cigarettes, drinking alcohol, and staring at a typewriter with a blank piece of white paper in it, and just fuming at humanity that way. So the gist of it is really very basic that he's been sent by his publisher to visit her and try to coerce her into writing another installment in the Ripley novels.
And it's very much a two-hander, and this is where I should quickly interject that one reason it's a two-hander-- there are other characters, but essentially two-hander is because the screenplay by Joanna Murray-Smith is based on her own 2014 play, "Switzerland". So you can imagine it working on stage with essentially just the two of them in Highsmith's living room and trading volleys back and forth, endearments, and insults, and all that back and forth here. So it has that chamber quality to it because of the source material.
But here's where, much as I like the film, I pull back a bit from it. Obviously, I'm a Helen Mirren fan, and she really delivers as Patricia Highsmith. And yes, she's on screen quite a bit. But push come to shove, the movie's really more about him than it is about her. It's more about that invented character, and indeed, the fact that it's not a coincidence that his last name is Ridgeway. And while we're talking about Rs in that respect, well, there's Ripley too. So it's like Ridgeway-slash-Ripley.
Because what will happen is, as he tries to get her into the dynamics of writing another installment in the Ripley book series, she's like, well, what would you do with that kind of thing? And this is where he almost becomes a co-author. Well, what about this or that? So as those things are verbally described, they also get shown to us visually. At various points in the film, it's deliberately a gray zone as to, well, are we watching somehow a projection of Ripley, or is this Ridgeway as Ripley, or where are we with that? And the film is interesting at that level.
But again, my reservation is even though that's worthwhile, it really puts the focus and most of the running time on that invented male character. Not that Highsmith disappears completely, but she sometimes will be gone for 10 or 15 minutes of a clip, and then pop up for a few acerbic comments and so on. So maybe it's selfish on my part, but I wanted more of Patricia Highsmith here. Because there's so much I would like to know in terms of, has she always been so sour on humanity, more about her domestic life or almost lack of one.
What happens for Mirren is that she very incisively presents the character, but then it's sitting or smoking in place. It's just there. You're not going to go any deeper or further with her. It's just what was established, and indelibly, but still just established and there it is. And if there's much character development, or movement, or just physical movement, it's coming more from the invented male character.
Marie, let me get your take on this, because again, really it's a very enjoyable film. I liked it, but I just kept thinking that the balance had tipped in a way that was not unexpected so much as just more unwanted. I didn't want it to tip so much in his favor, his running time.
MARIE WESTHAVER:
I think they do a good job of making Patricia Highsmith as a sort of enigma. If that was the intent, they do a good job with that. Plus, it turns into a story within a story, which is populated by the people who are not Patricia Highsmith, as if she might be writing it, for lack of a better way to put it.
I wanted to mention that Helen Mirren shot all of her scenes in two weeks. So I think if they had thought, we should have another scene here where we return to her, they may not have been able to do that, given that she'd already shot her scenes. For people who are listening to this who like to, whenever we mention another movie, want to write it down, I would underscore several times The Queen. Absolutely brilliant performance by Helen Mirren. I always think of her as inspector Jane Tennison from, I think it was Masterpiece Theater. And who could forget her in Caligula?
She's in everything. Things you would never expect, you end up finding her. And she almost disappears into this role, which I think she enjoyed because there's lots of opportunities to play a really complex villain. And I think she just enjoys sinking her teeth into that.
I wanted to mention, though, that not for nothing, they have a whole strangers on a train set up which I found enjoyable with Olivia Cooke in it. Gives you another character to follow, but also reminds you that the reason you probably have heard of Patricia Highsmith is from the book and movie Strangers on a Train, which Hitchcock made.
MIKE GIULIANO:
No, I absolutely love the Hitchcock connection there, because without spoiling everything within this storyline, strangers do meet on a train. It's very direct with making that reference, and it's handled well within it. And this is very much a story about storytelling.
The one missed opportunity I thought was, even though it does essentially become a story within a story, without spoiling anything here, I would have loved the notion of, well, if Patricia Highsmith's not willing to write the next installment, maybe he can and should. In other words, he would do the writing and have her name on it or something. I mean, there's a quasi-spoiler because it doesn't go that route, but I would have been tempted to do that. Have him sit down at the typewriter, have him write this up.
The other thing I love in that respect, too-- and I very much respect what you're saying there, and it's a tough creative decision here. What I'm respecting here is that Highsmith fundamentally remains enigmatic. She's kind of mysterious. You can't quite crack her that way. And to what extent should we or should we try to? So there is no ready answer to that. Because I would like to see her on screen more and more development.
But you're right. It's at the risk of maybe some sort of conventional explanation. And she does offer a little bit by way of an unhappy childhood and this and that. But a lot of people have unhappy childhoods, but they don't turn out to be such monsters as she can be. And she really can be mean. She really has a mean streak in her. So anyway, that's an imponderable as to how one would handle that.
But I did like the kind of narrative game playing, a story within a story, and yes, strangers on a train. And one aspect of strangers on a train that very directly factors into the plot that I won't otherwise spoil here is just simply that if you meet a stranger on the train, you want to quickly surmise what's their identity. But then you realize this is a situation where people assume identities.
And also, to be sympathetic to our male protagonist here, he's been sent to her home, and the moment he arrives, she wants to throw him out. Imagine you've gone from New York to Switzerland, and she's not only not asking you to stay initially, she says, well, leave. Get out of my house, kind of thing.
And then it goes from there. Of course, you know he's going to end up staying because, after all, it was a stage play. You don't want the play to end after 10 minutes. And likewise, in the movie, you want to have some substance to it.
But what I found really sympathetic about him at that respect is, just as she's really mean-- and this hasn't been commented on much-- his publisher back in New York that we hear from in a series of phone calls, I think is just as mean and unreasonable. Patricia Highsmith, at one end, or this nasty publisher or publishers rep at the other end. And the poor guy is between a rock and a hard place. He's really in a fix here. And I think it does make him very sympathetic as a character.
MARIE WESTHAVER:
It really does. I'm thinking about Tom Ripley and how that whole character is about assuming somebody else's identity. They call the five books about Tom Ripley the Ripliad. And so the conceit of the movie is that, what if there was a sixth one? What if that wasn't the last one? But what I want people to understand, if you watch any of the movies about Ripley, they actually take out the most important thing about him, which is that he gets away with it. In the movies, they have to tie it up with a bow, and nobody can really get away with murder kind of thing, like the production code.
But the point of Tom Ripley is that he gets away with it. And I think that's key to understanding this character we're seeing Helen Mirren play as Patricia Highsmith. That kind of cynicism where instead of tying it up with a bow, make sure nobody gets away with anything bad, it's some sort of moral centering, to just insist that, no, this is a truly amoral character and revel in it is something that is actually missing when you watch the movies that's in the books.
MIKE GIULIANO:
Well, you're right. She's an essentially enigmatic character in a lot of ways. And we can readily understand the surface malice. There's no mistaking some of the meanness. But as to what's underlying it, what's really behind that. But what's curious about this film, and it's one of the things I do like is even though he is ostensibly our protagonist and much more sympathetic, as I keep saying, in a nagging way, we got to wonder about him in terms of, well, to what extent is he enigmatic? Does he perhaps have another agenda, or untapped desires or ambitions or something?
And that's where, again, without spoiling anything in the story, you realize that, well, we all have a game plan, or we all have identities we are or would like to be. And when opportunity presents itself, what do we do in that situation? And you can imagine in a series of novels how well it works, because Ripley himself is like an empty vessel in some ways. He doesn't seem to have an identity because he can assume identity so readily. Maybe what we think is the immediately likable identity of this guy coming out from New York to visit the nasty old novelist-- well, he's a good guy, or is anyone entirely good, or don't we all have somehow hidden agendas or identities we'd like to explore.
And so if you meet a stranger on a train, who do you present yourself as? If you're going to meet the novelist, you have your official agenda there. But what might you be harboring inside that you would like? And I think the film does a really good job of making us question some of our initial assumptions about character.
MARIE WESTHAVER:
There is one movie called Ripley's Game that has John Malkovich and Dougray Scott in it, which I will recommend solely for the scene in the train where there's at least five people murdered in a train bathroom. If you've ever been in one of those bathrooms on a train, they're not that big. It would be difficult to kill one person, much less five. But it's a fascinating and wonderfully shot scene worth the price of admission just for that.
But that does bring us to the end of this episode. We will see you next time at the movies.
MIKE GIULIANO:
We'll see you then.
Outro
[music fades down]
Podcast Producer:
Thanks for tuning in. If you enjoyed what you just heard, we have a whole universe of podcasts waiting for you. Simply search Dragon Podcasts wherever you get your podcasts. You can also explore our full lineup and discover new shows at podbean.com/dragonpodcasts. That's podbean.com/dragonpodcasts.
[music ends]
Sense and Sensibility & A Talent For Murder